As I was browsing through Twitter this morning looking for some inspiration to write, I came across a Tweet from a major contributor to the Ed Tech Twitterverse. She was asked to put away her laptop at a meeting because it was distracting to the presenter. REALLY!!! Who is the meeting for? The presenter or the audience? I think one could argue the only reason the presenter is there in the first place, is because the audience has shown up! Don't tell me to put away my laptop, iPad, cell phone, iPod Touch, etc...
I get worked up when I read Tweets like this. It is sad that this happens every day at meetings and conferences all around the world. I challenge people who think laptops, iPads, iPods, cell phones, etc... are distracting to attend a "technology" conference and watch the audience. The audience might have 2-4 devices on their lap, but they aren't "distracted". They are "actively" engaged in the information. They are on Google searching the presenters name and topic to learn more, they are Tweeting quotes and links about the topic, they are blogging about their experiences! If you are telling them to put away their devices, then you better actively engage them/me!
Apply this same concept to the classroom. Are we asking our kids to do the same thing? Do you think they want to be actively engaged in their learning? Are we meeting those needs?
Don't get me wrong, there are times when the devices should be away or closed. We need to educate our young people on when those times are appropriate. Is total banning or outlawing the answer? Did it work during prohibition? Wait...now I am comparing the electronic device policies of our schools to prohibition!! Ok, that might be a little stretch! Think about it! What are we teaching our kids by telling them they CAN'T use these devices during their learning? We are teaching them that it is NOT ok to be actively engaged in learning, all because "we" (teachers and administration) are too scared about what the students "might" do when given the opportunity to use devices with their learning. We are teaching them that the only way to learn is to sit, listen, and regurgitate the information I just told you. Extend/expand their learning! Actively engage them in the learning process!
What Would You Do?
Think about this example. A student is caught texting in your classroom during your "exciting" lecture; you scold them, take their phone away. Later in the hour, you receive a text from one of your family members. Do you check it while the students are independently working on their worksheet?.......... I bet you do! Why is it ok for you to check your text, but not the students? Is it because your use was appropriate and the timing was appropriate? Or better yet, do you check your texts during inservice days while listening to a speaker? I know the answer is yes for some of you! Why is it OK for you to do the same thing you scold students for in your classroom? Who is going to teach them appropriate use?
Teach appropriate use and how to properly use the "tool" in your classroom. Set CLEAR expectations for your students. If a student uses his/her pencil to write a nasty note to a friend, do you take their paper and pencil away? What will you do if a student uses the device inappropriately? Will the consequence fit the crime? (Wow! This paragraph is a whole blog post in and of itself!)
Some of your students are like the woman at the beginning of this post that was told to put her laptop away. They are active learners who can multitask and take in just as much information as the person sitting next to them. Teach appropriate use, and SHOW/MODEL appropriate use.